Do you love the Deli-Style Marinated Mushrooms at the Antipasto Bars? Then you will love this 10 Minute Easy Italian Marinated Mushrooms Recipe! Make your own at a fraction of the price.
I LOVE the marinated mushrooms at the Antipasto Bars you find at the grocery stores. They are so expensive though. I usually see the Antipasto Bars priced at $10.99 a pound. If I am lucky, I come across one at $8.99 a pound. Those little mushrooms quickly add up in weight. So I thought to myself, why not make my own deli-style marinated mushrooms?
This post contains affiliate links. I have partnered with Pomora Olive Oil. They send me quarterly batch of their newest olive oils in exchange for a post. I receive a small compensation from any olive oil orders at no additional cost to you.
I received my fall collection of Pomora Olive Oils. This batch consisted of a basil, garlic, and white truffle infused olive oil assortment. I have tried every one and they are all fantastic! The garlic infused olive oil has a lovely light garlic flavor without overpowering the olive oil. It works beautifully with the marinated mushrooms.
Read this post for more information on why I love Pomora Olive Oil!
How to Make Italian Marinated Mushrooms
These 10 Minute Easy Italian Marinated Mushrooms are so easy to make and quite frankly better tasting than the ones you find in the deli! You can make as much as you want at a fraction of the cost.
To make them:
- Clean the mushrooms really well.
- Cook them in the vinegar/water combination.
- Toss them in olive oil and seasonings.
- Chill and serve when ready!
Extra tips:
- *I remove my stems. You don’t have to. If you remove your stems, you can use them in a broth or freeze them for a later use.
- *If you only have the plain Extra Virgin Pomora Olive Oil, you can just add 1 crushed garlic clove.
Can you marinate mushrooms overnight?
This cooking process for marinating the mushrooms works similar to pickling. It is not a true pickling process because of the vinegar/water ratio, and the addition of olive oil. However, because the mushrooms are marinated immediately, you will remove them from the extra vinegar to prevent any extra unwanted marinating. You don’t want the mushrooms too strong or to become mushy. The mushrooms are better served a little chilled or at room temperature. It is best to cool them off a bit before serving. Therefore, you can make them a head of time before serving and store any leftovers in an airtight container overnight. They will remain tasty up to 3 days.
Do Marinated Mushrooms need to be refrigerated?
If you are not eating the mushrooms immediately, you will want to store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator. However, the olive oil will congeal a bit as they get cold. To solve this, take out the mushrooms a few minutes before serving to allow them to reach room temperature. The olive oil will melt into the desired consistency. You will not want to use a different type of oil. Any other oils will change the taste and it will not be as good in flavor.
Are you looking for some more inspirations to add to a cold antipasto platter? Try these recipes:
- Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese Cucumber Bites
- Jalapeno Cilantro Hummus
- Baba Ganoush
- Fire and Ice Pickles
- Marinated Olives and Cheese
- Marinated Cheese Tray
- Low Carb Asparagus and Roast Beef Rollups
- Cuban Sandwich On A Stick
- Buffalo Deviled Eggs
10 Minute Easy Italian Marinated Mushrooms Recipe
Ingredients
- 2 lbs fresh mushrooms
- 1 cup white wine vinegar
- 1/2 cup water
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 1/4 tsp red pepper flakes
- 2 tbs Pomora Garlic Olive Oil
- 1 tbs fresh chopped parsley
Instructions
- Clean 2lbs of fresh mushrooms.
- Remove stems. (You can keep the stems. It is a personal preference.)
- In a pot, bring 1 cup white wine vinegar and 1/2 cup water to a boil.
- Add mushrooms. (You can cook mushrooms in batches if you run out of room in the pan. Keep the vinegar mixture in the pan for the next batch and only remove the mushrooms.)
- Cook mushrooms for about 5 minutes or until mushrooms shrink in size and have softened.
- Drain mushrooms from any extra vinegar mixture.
- Mix mushrooms with 1/2 tsp salt, 1/4 tsp red pepper flakes, 2 tbs Pomora Garlic Olive Oil, and 1 tbs fresh chopped parsley.
- Allow to cool and serve immediately or refrigerate in a sealed container until ready to eat.
Video
Nutrition
Katie says
I am so glad you and your guests loved the mushrooms. Thank you for sharing. You made my day!
Beverly says
I used your recipe for two antipasti I made over the holidays. Every one thaught I had spent a lot of money to serve Bowles of your mushroom. Thank you for making me look good!
Katie says
Thank you Gwen! I hope you enjoy them!!
Gwen says
Thanks so much! I found mushrooms on sale yesterday. I really LOVE the olive bar version. Thanks for the recommendation and recipe.
karrie @ Tasty Ever After says
These mushrooms look incredible! So much better for you and less expensive than the ones in jars or on the salad bar in the store. I’ve got to try this olive oil soon too 🙂